You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Wordsmiths Fiction Week 4: Season 24 – The Family Secret

in #fiction-s24wk43 months ago

Hellofajrularfst @, thank you so much for taking part in Week of the Steemit Challenge - Season 24! We truly appreciate the time and creativity you put into your entry. Your assessment, including feedback and scores based on our evaluation criteria, is provided below.

CriteriaMarks
Story Setting & World-Building: You have tried well but it's not the story according to the theme1.5/3
Theme & Message: Your story doesn't match the prompt in our contest post1/2
Formatting & Presentation:1/2
Originality & Uniqueness:1.5/3
Total5/10

Feedback
Please read the rules of the contest, thank you!


mod template image.webp

Moderated by: @dove11

Sort:  

Hello Sir @dove11

Actually, I don't really care about the score you gave, because I think it's subjective.

But I am confused by the reasons you gave in the assessment, as seen below:

Screenshot_20250514_110223.jpg

Show me which rules I need to read again?

And let's look together at the beginning of the story prompt:

Who is Jeremy? Why had he been kept secret for so long? Does he even know he is part of this inheritance?

So you think those questions are not answered in the story I made? That's a shame!

Maybe I also need to hear a response from @waqarahmadshah

I wasn't the one who moderated your post. You will get your answer from @dove11.

I just wanted to see what you thought as part of the challenge organizing team. I think as a team member you should have the same operational standards, or at least have a discussion together. Are you guys doing that?

Loading...

I am here to help you @fajrularifst, I will answer your query on Sunday evening so not to give out the clues. Have a nice time.

Does that mean you can't answer what I'm asking? You should be able to explain it easily. This really seems unprofessional.

I said I will answer you on Sunday!