You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: "Wordsmiths Fiction Week 4: Season 24 – The Family Secret"

in #fiction-s24wk43 months ago

Hello @shahid76, thank you so much for taking part in Week of the Steemit Challenge - Season 24! We truly appreciate the time and creativity you put into your entry. Your assessment, including feedback and scores based on our evaluation criteria, is provided below.

CriteriaMarks
Story Setting & World-Building: You have done well with the prompt but I did not understand who "left a letter for her that said, "Your name is Thomas Morgan" and nothing else. "2.75/3
Theme & Message: You left a couple of loose points here like, "How did they know the address of a building since they did not meet the lawyer or there was no mention of any building in the will. You could have scored better if had mentioned a meeting of these three with the lawyer.1.5/2
Formatting & Presentation: You did okay here1.75/2
Originality & Uniqueness: Your theme sounds original and a nice message.2.75/3
Total8.75/10

Feedback
You have done well in your story but for a few minor oversights.


mod template image.webp

Moderated by: @dove11

Sort:  

@dove11 sir, thank you so much for reviewing my post.

Story Setting & World-Building: You have done well with the prompt, but I did not understand who "left a letter for her that said, "Your name is Thomas Morgan' and nothing else. "

Morgan's mother left a letter for her son before she died. In that letter, Morgan's name was Thomas Morgan. There was nothing else.

My answer is right there in your question itself. Please read and analyze yourself.

"Left a letter for her"
"Her?"
Your name is Thomas Morgan, was that letter for Thomas Morgan?

Please do not make things complicated because then more questions will surface. Like was Jeremy's name Thomas?

Why the mother, "left a letter for "her' that said, "Your name is Thomas Morgan'

Why did she use the term, "for her?"

Have a nice time.

@dove11, sir,
Sorry, it's a mistake. It will be him. That means Morgan.
I will be more alert next time.

Hi, @dove11,

Thank you for your contribution. Your post has been manually curated.


- Delegate to @ecosynthesizer and vote @symbionts as a witness to support us.
- Explore Steem using our Steem Blockchain Explorer
- Easily create accounts on Steem using JoinSteem