The ROI on becoming a musician | Church music
I'm so grateful that I'm a part of the steemit community. I feel like I can voice my thoughts and the community will respond in appropriate ways. Not too long ago, my friend @organduo and I were discussing the issue of music, the church (Catholic—RC specifically) and finances. Why is it that musicians have to work and fight extremely hard to make a living? Unless you are in the upper echelon of the mainstream music world, a musician's financial wellbeing is pretty grim.
Why bother with all those years of lessons, examinations, diplomas, competitions, study and practice if the ROI is bad? With any other profession, you can basically decide to go to university after high school and study for 3-5 years and come out with a degree (then get a decent paying job). Whereas a musician who decides to study music at a tertiary level must already know how to play their chosen instrument and be at a suitable standard (as determined by the institution). In Australia, even if someone has any qualifications in music the career prospects are grim. Apart from pursing a performance career (e.g. see "How can concert organist make a living"), a fresh graduate can't even teach in schools without taking further education qualifications. They may teach privately, however, but the average income and for private music teachers is far lagging behind other professions.
It boggles my mind as to why musicians, hard working and talented, are often the least acknowledged and compensated in comparison to any other profession. I stress the words, HARD WORKING, because even talent needs to be trained and refined. Now I haven't even touched on musicians and the church yet...
Music ministry is such an integral part of any church's liturgical life. When something is important shouldn't we nurture, protect, support and grow it? In my experience, it seems that the Catholic church has somewhat "dropped the ball" in regards to music ministry in comparison to other Christian denominations. Of course, this also applies to keeping instruments in playable condition:
"The pipe organ is to be held in high esteem in the Latin Church, since it is its traditional instrument, the sound of which can add a wonderful splendor to the Church's ceremonies and powerfully lift up men's minds to God and higher things."
Musicam Sacram #62
Musicians should be trained, capable and be aware of the sprit of the liturgy:
"It is highly desirable that organists and other musicians should not only possess the skill to play properly the instrument entrusted to them: they should also enter into and be thoroughly aware of the spirit of the liturgy, so that even when playing ex tempore, they will enrich the sacred celebration according to the true nature of each of its parts, and encourage the participation of the faithful"
Musicam Sacram #67
If we want the church to grow (in faith, hope and charity), then we must plant roots and invest in all the things that make it beautiful. Investing zero dollars will yield zero dollars, pay peanuts—get monkeys, "you get what you pay for".
Interested to hear what others think...
To become a professional musician is perhaps more a vocation than a sane or wise career choice. Only the very talented make a career with giving concerts. And probably a bit of luck is needed as well. The most end up as teachers and hobbyists.
To become a professional organist is even more a vocation. Organ music and church services are strongly linked. So much so that the potential the instrument has is seldom realised by people raised in families without binding to any church . The chances of a concert career are even smaller than for a violinist or a pianist.
On the bright side: there's the possibility to become church organist, a possibility lacking for other instrumentalists. There is no such thing as a church hoboist.
I cannot imagine anyone choosing a life in music if there is not a strong love for the instrument. And though that in itself does not buy you any food, it is the motivation and urge that drives you forward. Without it, you cannot invest the time and energy to reach and maintain a high level of playing.
Any musician who is in it for the money won't make it (unless very talented and very lucky)
Posted using Partiko Android
Yes, church music is definitely a vocation but still needs support (we are still human). When you mentioned teaching, it reminded me of this quote: “It's easier to get a job teaching how to do something than it is to get a job actually doing it.” Really looking forward to @organduo’s take on this!
Posted using Partiko iOS
Of course. Good topic...
Posted using Partiko Android
Also, countries such as the US and UK are much better environments for church musicians.
Posted using Partiko iOS
I think @laputis can express her thoughts about this too.
Posted using Partiko Android
I think organists work extremely hard to make a living because now the church officials no longer understand music intimately. In the Middle Ages the only musicians where monks. So they were part of the clergy. And therefore they were respected. But gradually musical evolution led to the situation where only professional musicians had sufficient skill and training to create and perform music. So they were separated from the clergy status. Lost their privileges. Now we have what we have.
Posted using Partiko Android
Thank you contrabourdon! You've just received an upvote of 37% by artturtle!
Learn how I will upvote each and every one of your posts
Please come visit me to see my daily report detailing my current upvote power and how much I'm currently upvoting.
Help Support Artopium & ArtoLabs
I'm asking all my friends and supporters to consider downloading the new Brave Browser as way of helping me to raise capital for Artopium & ArtoLabs. This costs you absolutely nothing, but I get a referral reward if you use Brave. If you've enjoyed using @ArtTurtle please consider doing this. I wrote this very comprehensive article about this here:
https://steemit.com/brave/@artopium/support-artopium-using-brave-browser
Congratulations @contrabourdon! You have completed the following achievement on the Steem blockchain and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :
You can view your badges on your Steem Board and compare to others on the Steem Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word
STOP
To support your work, I also upvoted your post!